The global site of the UK's leading magazine for automation, motion engineering and power transmission
18 July, 2024

Twitter link

What is the real cost of owning a motor?

01 September, 2018

Rob Wood, ABB’s sales manager for LV motors in the UK, examines the true cost of owning and operating an electric motor over a typical 20-year lifespan. His conclusions are startling.

The purchase price of a new motor is normally less than 3% of the total lifecycle costs of the motor. To see the real cost of any electric motor, therefore, you need to consider the total cost of ownership (TCO):

TCO = purchase price + cost of running + cost of not running.

The cost of running is about 70–95% of total costs and is based on the energy price per kilowatt-hour, and the annual running hours over a 20-year lifespan. The cost of NOT running – or the cost of unplanned production stops – is 2-30% of total costs and is based on one major unplanned motor failure over its lifetime.

When calculating the cost of running, the motor’s efficiency is an important factor. For a 315kW motor with a 95.5% efficiency used in a continuous process, the input power on which you will be charged is 329.8kW (315/0.955). If the energy cost is 11p/kWh, and the motor runs for 8,400 hours per year, then the cost of running the motor over a 20-year lifetime is:

329.8 x 0.11 x 8400 x 20 = £ 6,094,704

Compared to the original purchase cost, the cost of running is extremely high (£18,000 vs £6,094,704).

The cost of NOT running is the cost of unplanned downtime each year. A typical motor used in the oil and gas industry can cost an estimated £220,000 per hour if it fails. Assuming one major breakdown of 10 hours in its 20-year lifespan, the cost of NOT running is £220,000 x 10 = £2,200,000. In a continuous process, a single hour-long production break can cost more than 10 times more than the motor that caused it.

Now the total cost of ownership looks like this:

£18,000 + £6,094,704 + £2,200,000 = £8,312,704.

For every £1 spent on purchasing, it could end up costing you more than £450 to own the motor over its lifetime. Even halving your purchase cost to £9,000, has minimal effect on the TCO. But if you can reduce your running cost and cost of not running by 5%, it will have a significant impact:

5% of £6,094,704 + £2,200,000 = £414,735.00.

Clearly, when purchasing an electric motor, the costs of running and not running should be considered in addition to the purchase price.

  • To view a digital copy of the latest issue of Drives & Controls, click here.

    To visit the digital library of past issues, click here

    To subscribe to the magazine, click here



"Do you think that robots create or destroy jobs?"



Most Read Articles