25 Jul 2024


Cogging-free PCB motor helps to control cameras remotely

An exploded view of the handwheel controller incorporating the PCB-stator motor

A Los Angeles company that develops equipment for the film industry has used a motor with a stator formed from a PCB (printed circuit board) to solve a problem with hand-wheel systems used to operate film cameras remotely.

Cinematographer Boyd Hobbs founded the company, Nodo Film Systems, in 2018 with the aim of creating smarter film-making equipment. The following year, he launched his Inertial Wheels controls which introduced simulated inertia to hand wheels for camera operators, allowing them to operate cameras remotely and to obtain haptic feedback as they worked.

However, Hobbs faced a problem in achieving this feedback. With conventional motors, as torque increases, so does the cogging effect. Although there are specialised brushless motors that overcome cogging, they tend to be expensive.

So he turned to Massachusetts-based E-Circuit Motors (ECM) which makes motors with PCB stators which, it claims, eliminate cogging. Using dedicated software from ECM, Nodo designed a custom wheel assembly that integrates a PCB motor with a hand wheel to create a direct-drive mechanism. Using duplex wireless connections, the system can operate cameras remotely up to a mile (1.6km) away. With a hard-wired connection, the range is around 600m.

The new inertial wheels generate three times more peak motor torque than the previous version, while using the slotless motors are able to achieve realistic feedback beyond the weight of mechanical gearheads. The PCB Stator motors also cost much less than cogging-free brushless motors.

The motors stabilise and smooth the wheel movements. The “weightiness” of the wheels can be adjusted to suit the shot, or be switched mid-shot using presets. When the camera stops at a limit, so do the wheels. The operator can feel when a limit is hit, with the motor bringing the wheel to a stop precisely where the camera is.

Nodo plans to start selling its Inertia Wheels Max controllers later this year in two- and three-axis versions.

“The result of this collaboration is a major step forward for both the film industry and high-torque, high-precision haptics,” says Hobbs. “The combination of torque, precision, flexible form factor, and ease of manufacturing did not exist before these motors. It’s an inspiring and revolutionary combination of technology.”

Nodo is working on new products that use the PCB stator motors. It also plans to offer integration, motor/driver design and firmware development services to other companies in the film industry, as well as those from other sectors wanting to develop haptics-based products.

ECM claims that its motors that are lighter, faster, quieter, more energy- and design-efficient, for a wide range of uses. The company has already worked with companies in the robotics, HVAC, consumer electronics, e-mobility, medical, aerospace and defence sectors.

E-Circuit Motors (ECM)Twitter  LinkedIn  Facebook